DA Image

All audience reviews of Prem Ratan Dhan Payo

  • Prem Ratan Dhan Payo: Review

    Merkwürdige Liebe

    Desimartini | Updated - November 12, 2015 13:34 PM IST
    3.3DM (6355 ratings)

    Verdict - A bland and banal, if not unbearable ode to the institution of family.

    Prem Ratan Dhan PayoWatch trailerRelease date : November 12, 2015

    It should come as no surprise that Prem Ratan Dhan Payo endlessly parades retrograde ideals - it is after all Sooraj Barjatya's yet another loving ode to the big fat Indian family and traditions - but what he manages here is quite something, given that this movie (somehow) got made in 2015.
    It's taken for granted that it's only the bad guys in this movie who smoke and drink while the good guys only eat vegetarian food. But here's the deal: there's a prince, Vijay Singh, of the mythical kingdom of Pritampura, whose estranged sisters rudely rebuff each of his attempts at reconciling with them. Here, Barjatya wishes to establish how callous and spiteful they really are. Had this been a soap opera, these women would have worn huge bindis and bulky jewellery to help Barjatya reinforce his point. But here, he goes a step further: they go to school, and one of them plays football. Oh and of course, they are his step-sisters.
    To be fair, Barjatya does bring this thread to a close in a rather nice sequence involving a football match (the "Boy" and "Girl" caps from Hum Aapke Hai Koun are replaced by scorecards that read "Kings" and "Queens") and the narrative has the characters take surprising decisions at times, but here precisely lies the problem - his establishment of the conveniently labeled good and bad guys is so socio-politically charged in its implications with regard to his naively virtuous worldview that the sequences he does pull off are robbed of their emotional punch.
    This is the kind of film that feels like it belongs to a different time. It doesn't feel contemporary. There is, for instance, a Ram Leela sequence with endearing local flavour which serves as an entry scene for the hero Prem (Salman Khan, who else) that's infused with playful pranks and gentle tomfoolery which should have been warmly charming, but leaves you cold because Barjatya's idea of fun is deriding wayward youth who dare to joke about religious icons. A song crops up every five minutes - literally, no hyperbole - and a thoughtful filmmaker would've made this one hell of a romp, but the less said about the horrific mishmash that is the music, the better. It feels like Himesh Reshammiya was briefed that the songs have to retain the essence of the music from the 90s Barjatya films but must also sound modern - and the result is exactly how someone like Himesh would interpret that description. There's a dreamlike song sequence in the second half set in a gorgeously designed garden which someone like Sanjay Leela Bhansali would have made gold out of.
    Like Bhansali, who made that other (rather underrated) Salman-Sonam (anti-)romance in an equally mythical setting, Barjatya is a filmmaker clearly not without strengths. Had he eschewed "story", shunned conventional character and plot development with token twists and instead gone full crazy-indulgent on us, we would've landed with interesting material. But he's after something else; his politics keep coming in way of his unique style. And while Bhansali's positively unrealistic spaces seem to reflect the psychology of his characters, the grandeur in Prem Ratan Dhan Payo seems strangely divorced from its characters' mindstates, there's zero interaction between the film's overall mood and its aesthetics.
    But Prem Ratan Dhan Payo, instead of playing to its strengths, wants to tell a story. Which is as much of a disaster as the film itself - the plot kicks off when the aforementioned prince is about to dutifully marry Princess Maithili because his long-deceased father had fixed the match when the two were kids, and as one character in the film proclaims, it would be sinister to break the vow. Perhaps I should modify my earlier statement that Barjatya doesn't go full crazy-indulgent on us - he sure does, just that his own craziness adheres to good ol' tradition as much as his characters do.

more audience reviews

  • Samarpita Yashaswini
    Rated 2.0November 19, 2018

    Suraj Barjatya and Salman Khan’s latest fails to impress

    Suraj Barjatya and Salman Khan has always been a great combination, but not this time. Suraj Barjatya’s Prem Ratan Dhan Paayo is a recipe for disas...read more

  • Rahaf Junaid

    Rahaf Junaid

    1 Reviews
    Rated 5.0November 28, 2015


    one of salman khan best movies .. action , romance it has everything although its perfect for families I'm in love with every small detail in the m...read more

  • Saurabh Yadav

    Saurabh Yadav

    3 Reviews , 3 Followers
    Rated 2.0November 23, 2015

    Prem Ratan Dhan Payo

    It is more of a musical with weak script and story line than a family drama flick. The biggest disappointment was that even after being a musical, ...read more

  • Madan Mohan Marwah

    Madan Mohan Marwah

    387 Reviews , 23 Followers
    Rated 3.0November 19, 2015

    Prince Salman ,Princess Sonam, and their royal family in familiar musical drama

    This film is a comeback of sorts for director Sooraj Barjatya and his style of movie making along with his character Prem this time with a suffix D...read more

  • Ghanshyam Jha

    Ghanshyam Jha

    1 Reviews
    Rated 5.0November 19, 2015

    Awsome PRDP

    The movie is spectacular and worth watching. Salman acting is awsome and he had just won our heart. The sets and the locations specially sheesh ma...read more