DA Image

"Secret Superstar" Hindi film review - Terrific acts make this predictable film enjoyable

  • Sekhar GC

    Sekhar GC (623 DM Points)

    Rated 
    3.0
    Desimartini | Updated - November 06, 2017 12:44 PM IST
    3.7DM (9645 ratings)
    Secret SuperstarWatch trailerRelease date : October 19, 2017

    Set in Baroda, the story is of school-girl Insia, who is a gifted singer. She belongs to a conservative family, and while her mother associates with her daughter's musical aspirations, her father does not meet eye-to-eye with it, or her, and looks at her like a curse (being the girl-child). Her journey in fulfilling her dreams form the rest of the film.
    Now, in this, domestic violence is also nicely intertwined. And that part was appealing to me, and I would have loved to see that as a movie in itself. Instead of combining the two.
    First things that come to my mind, after watching this film:
    This is predictable fare, and has all the ingredients of a commercial success.
    It is melodramatic, and is over the top in many places, especially towards the end.
    But it does have very good performances, and that saves the film, in my view.
    The film belongs to the three main characters -
    1. Meher Vij as Insia's mother - I have no words to describe her acting in this one. The scenes between the mother and daughter and the camaraderie they share is mind-blowing, and a joy to watch, to say the least.
    2. Zaira Wasim as Insia Malik, as good as (say) Leonardo DiCaprio was in What's eating Gilbert Grape, the common factor being teenagers when they played their roles. To get an idea of how good she is, just watch her expressions when she trills and croons. Pah! Amm...mmaezing!
    3. Raj Arjun as Insia's father Farookh Malik, is nothing short of awesomeness! He breathes fire into his role and is so effective that one would feel like getting into the screen and punching his face. The best part about his role - he was controlled, and doesn't play the 'typical' bad guy.
    Aamir Khan plays the role of a good Samaritan, a rejected and dejected music director, and appears to be having a ball in his own production.
    The best thing about the film is that it is simple and unadulterated.
    Some things are hard to believe or digest, though, in the film - like how easily Insia gets a bazillion hits on YouTube, and how easily she becomes a superstar in a burkha; or for that matter her easy access to Bollywood music director Shakti Kumar.
    The question is whether director Advait Chandan can hold his own, without the backing of a superstar producer. Nonetheless, bravado and more than just brownie points to the young director for making a film about domestic violence and chasing dreams.
    An important lesson, again, to learn from this is that good publicity can take a film exponentially higher at the box-office. Which a film like Rukh clearly (and sadly) lacked.
    Spoiler: I'd have probably enjoyed the film more had they ended it at the airport, when Insia's mother finally stands-up for herself and her daughter. But no, for Bollywood commercial grounds, they had to drag it further and add melodrama with the cliched awards-function, speeches, blah blah...!
    My verdict: 3 out of 5. Watch it, for a hero's journey and for some out-of-the-world acting by Meher Vij and Zaira Wasim.
    - Sekhar, GCtheThinker.blogspot.com

more audience reviews

  • Shreya Agrawal

    40 Reviews, 1 Followers
    Rated 3.5September 17, 2018

    Secret Superstar Review- Zaira Wasim is surely the superstar in this film.

    A typical Bollywood melodramatic yet a heart- warming tale of Secret Superstar is a delight to watch which will make you leave the theatre with a h...read more

  • Samarpita Yashaswini

    47 Reviews, 0 Followers
    Rated 4.0September 12, 2018

    Powerful, gripping and crisp

    This film is about an ambitious girl Insia, who would go to any heights to achieve her dream of becoming a famous singer and who is very close to h...read more

  • Khushboo Kumar

    2 Reviews, 0 Followers
    Rated 4.5January 11, 2018

    Secret Superstar Review : Not the one to be missed.

    Written and Directed by the debutant Advait Chandan, 'Secret Superstar' takes one on a high-low emotional ride. From the heartwarming mother-daught...read more

  • Sony Sharma

    25 Reviews, 0 Followers
    Rated 4.0November 9, 2017

    Motherhood is here!

    Mother and Daughter relationshipis the main aim of the movie. How a mother sacrifices everything to make her daughrer a star. Starring Aamir Khan, ...read more

  • Sekhar GC

    43 Reviews, 0 Followers
    Rated 3.0October 31, 2017

    "Secret Superstar" Hindi film review - Terrific acts make this predictable film enjoyable

    Set in Baroda, the story is of school-girl Insia, who is a gifted singer. She belongs to a conservative family, and while her mother associates wit...read more