DA Image

All audience reviews of West is West

  • The Twain Shall Meet

    Mehul Suri (50 DM Points)

    Rated 
    3.5
    Desimartini | Updated - June 10, 2011 15:18 PM IST
    3.3DM (141 ratings)
    West is WestWatch trailerRelease date : June 10, 2011



    Rudyard Kiplings famous words did hold true for the prequel East Is East. But the myth is broken in the second part. It was about time. The film takes off 10-15 years after the first one when all the kids have moved out and only the little Sajid remains. Remember the young boy who got castrated in the first one? Well the story is about him and his tradition-defying ways. To set him right, his father George Khan (Om Puri) takes him back to Pakistan. But once there, he himself faces the dilemma of balancing the east and the west in him.

    The story has its heart in the right place but the screenplay meanders before finally picking up pace towards the last half an hour of the movie. Ayub Khan, the writer of the play and the subsequent movie East Is East wields the pen yet again to bring this delightful tale to screen. But the fun is missing. What we see is many emotional moments set against the barren backdrop and sufiana music. First time feature director Andy DeEmmony does a competent job but fails to capture the vibrancy of the sub-continent culture.

    Om Puri, one of the finest actors in our country has off late managed to sleep walk through his angry old man roles. The flawed, somewhat human yet adorable George of East Is East is missing from this one. Aquib Khan who plays Sajid gives us a good case of the teenage rebel stuck in a conflicting world. But his character is too straightly written for any scope of jumping to the next level. Ila Arun as the first wife of George in Pakistan emits a subtle woman power that is characteristic of our woman. But the Punjabi accent is not quite right. Which is the case with most of the actors, especially Vijay Raj.

    East Is East brought us a story which tickled and tugged at the heart strings. West Is West, though the right step in the direction fails to match up to its predecessor. But I guess thats the case with most sequels. Its a film that will hit home with the Diaspora. The Desis might be a bit disappointed. Still 3 and a half stars for old times sake.

more audience reviews

  • Ramesh

    Ramesh

    1 Reviews
    Rated 3.0August 03, 2011

    west..

    Nice..

  • Abhishek

    Abhishek

    1 Reviews
    Rated 2.5June 20, 2011

    Bore movie

    The conflicts between father and son, and husband and wives begin to wear thin, and except for an elevating moment of confrontation between George'...read more

  • Ambadas Raut

    Ambadas Raut

    1 Reviews
    Rated 3.0June 15, 2011

    good coemdy

    good coemdy

  • Smita Vyas Kumar

    Smita Vyas Kumar

    554 Reviews , 451 Followers
    Rated 2.5June 11, 2011

    Ho hum

    I had loved East is East and looked forward to the sequel and like all sequels it disappointed me. I guess when you watch a movie the characters ke...read more

  • Mehul Suri

    Mehul Suri

    73 Reviews , 1 Followers
    Rated 3.5June 10, 2011

    The Twain Shall Meet

    Rudyard Kiplings famous words did hold true for the prequel East Is East. But the myth is broken in the second part. It was about time. The film ta...read more