Why Katappa killed Baahubali? Five Crazy Fan theories we found on Quora

Updated : April 27, 2017 06:28 PM IST

Why Katappa killed Baahubali? Five Crazy Fan theories we found on Quora

Here is the first one:

"1st scene is both bhallaladeva and bijjaladeva will disuss about bahubali and sivagami and will plan to kill bahubali.

Bahubali owns mahismati kingdom.Bhallaladeva and bijjalaladeva jealous about bahubali victory.Then bhallaladeva ordered kattapa to kill bahubali otherwise he will kill sivagami.

Then Both Kattapa and bahubali together play some drama to save sivagami. Kattapa will tell bhallaladeva that bahubali had died. So, then he will not kill sivagami. Bahubali lives in secret place may be Kuntala where he fall in love with devasena.

After some years bahubali tried to kill bhallaladeva to take revenge, but unfortunately bhallaladeva will escape from bahubali attack,

Finally, he began to warn subbaraja(Who plays Anushka brother) king of Kuntala to kill bahubali other wise he will kill all kuntala people. So, forcefully subbaraju will kill bahubali and hand over Anushka to bhallaladeva.

At this this time Anushka give birth to sivudu and ask sivagami to save her child sivudu from bhallaladrteva by touching sivagami feet(Emotional part) with blood hand.

Then sivagami introduce sivudu to mahishmati people(Sivagami shouting moment in Bahubali-2 trailer-Amendra Bahubali).Mahismati people shouts Bahubali is back as Amerendra bahubali(Interval Bang).

Then, bhallaladeva ordered to his army to kill Amendra Bahubali,Since sivagami promised to devasena that she will save her child sivudu so, she try to save sivudu (Bahubali-1 introuduction).

Then bhallaladeva keeps devasena as a slave and he will punish all mahishmati people for supporting Bahubali.

After some years,Bhallaladeva came to know that bahubali son sivudu is live and will return back to take Mahismati kingdom then he again ordered kattapa to kill sivudu.

Again both sivudu and kattapa will plan to play drama but this time bhallaladeva will identify kattapa -sivudu drama and he will take revenge on kattapa and will kill him.

Finally,Sivudu will kill bhallaladeva (Climax fight)and takes mahishmati kingdom"

The second is by Hem Anand:

"My theory on : WHY KATTAPA KILLED BAHUBALI !!!

The story rewinds to the days when Amarendra Bahubali started ruling the kingdom. While Bahubali made many people reforms and solely enjoyed the people’s respect , Bhallala Deva / Palvaalthevan , the War Commander risked his life in indulging all kind of war activities. In the events of time he became a true monster and was in the serious quest of becoming the king of Makizhmathi/Mahishmathi. Though Sivagami felt rightful to her decision by witnessing the prosperity of Makizhmathi in Bahubali's reign it was her heart of a mother that lost peace on seeing her biological son Palvaalthevan totally overshadowed by Bahubali.

Days go past and It was acknowledged that a neighboring kingdom is forming allies with other small kingdoms to take down Makizhmathi as it possessed a huge potential threat to all other kingdoms. Palvaalthevan ,as the commander in chief was ordered to carry a secret mission to kill the War commander and the King of the neighboring kingdom to stop the war. Palvaalthevan, fighting fierce fully with his troop ,killed their war commander and destroyed the lead warriors . Palvaalthevan madly searches for the King to get him executed and finally finds him ,along with a lady warrior who played an unprecedented yet skillful attack at Palvaalthevan. kattappa in the act of rescue puts the warrior down and it happened to be Devasena , the princess of the neighboring kingdom. Meanwhile the King escapes and Palvaalthevan takes the princess home as captive and ties her to chains only to make her suffer. Upon seeing this kattappa feels guilty for being a part of it.

The humane king Bahubali comes to the rescue of Devasena and orders to relieve her from chains and makes sure she is treated with respect. The king and Devasena also had a moment with each other at their first encounter. Devsena with her unique blend of feminism and bravery impresses bahubali and he kind of falls in love with her . Devsena too involves with bahubali and they are mutually in love with each other. Sivagami acknowledges this.

Parallely Bijjala Deva / Pingaladevan does a master plan in which he intends Devasana to get married to his son so that he could have a kingdom of his own and become a king finally. Palavaallthevan develops a strong desire for Devasena but gets rejected on face upon approaching her. Pingaladevan discusses this with Sivagami ,as this could avoid any further war between kingdoms she approves of that. However, she wisely quotes 'Devasena shall be married to this kingdom' thinking Bahubali in her mind.

Devsena's father , the King disposes this and makes sure he would take down Makizhmathi. Sivagami, however Convinces Devasana for marriage by pointing out that this event would eventually make peace between kingdoms and save many innocent lives. Bahubali and Devasena gets married .This adds to the heat of Palvaaldevan and Sivagami knows that she has earned the true hatred of both Palvaaldevan and his supporters. But Sivagami always believed in making rightful decisions and stood by it whatsoever.

The king and the new queen ruled Makizhmathi to the likes of their people. Meanwhile the tension between the two kingdoms hit the surface as all the small kingdoms finally formed an ally and manipulated the king ,who now madly wanted to capture Makizhmathi and Makizhmathi in turn declares it an enemy kingdom. The allies who ran out of main soldiers in a previous attack by Makizhmathi now want to maximize their strength by indulging the common people in their warfare. As Bahubali too was preparing his kingdom for the war, Devasena was worried that this would cost the lives of many innocent people which would also demean the primary intentions of her marriage with Bahubali. She secretly takes Bahubali to the ally kingdom to make him understand things better. Bahubali witnesses sad scenes of children and women being forced to train for a war to match their strength with Makizhmathi. He sympathizes the people and made a promise to Devasena on his child that she is carrying to treat these people as his own people and protect them at any cost.

Bahubali then decided to go for peace talks which failed miserably and gets strongly suggested by Sivagami to go for a war before they could act to which he responds negative. Bahubali's ineffeciency to declare a war created ripples in the kingdom and eventually the council members were called for a meeting to decide the need for a new king. Votes got equally split between Bahubali and Palvaaldevan where Sivagami’s vote plays a decisive role. Sivagami, always being rightful to her decision wanted to protect her kingdom as she understands Bahubali's emotional attachment with the enemy kingdom could possess a danger to her kingdom. She votes Palvaaldevan and Bahubali steps down to be the war commander. It was ironic that Sivagami once preferred him for the kingdom for the same concern he had for innocent lives, but for her own 'Innocent lives' back then. Palvaaldevan,finally the King immediately declares the war.

As Palvaaldevan acknowledged Bahubali would not kill People on war he makes Kattappa the war commander and gives him a specific protocol which he had to obey in the war. Now Bahubali is just a warrior in Kattappa's troop, trying to save the innocent people of enemy kingdom. He requests kattappa to capture the child and lady warriors but not hurt them. Kattappa responds positive and they started capturing women and children without hurting. However a special troop arrives carrying Makizhmathi banner and started killing these captured people. Bahubali stands up against them and in the act of keeping up his promise he had to sword his own men. Now the next thing happening would be Kattappa backstabbing Bahubali as Balladeva tricked Kattappa by giving a war protocol that reads "I acknowledged there is a traitor in your troop. You will identify him as the one killing our own men and you have to retaliate by stabbing him in the back, which he deserves as a traitor. You shall carry this order as the true servant of Makizhmathi without any deviation". As Bahubali dies keeping up the promise on his child , Devasena gives birth to the child and “Mahendra Bahubali” was born out of the true promise of his noble father"Amerendara Bahubali" .

Sivagami gets to know of this from kattappa and saves the child in potential danger by sacrificing her life as she understands her decision went wrong and its sinful .Most of the people saved by Bahubali were slaved in Makizhmathi (they could be seen in the first part of the movie being so responsive to the word 'Bahubali' in the gold statue erection scene). Few others escaped from the enemy kingdom and forms a rebellion, only to rescue Devasena, their Queen from Palvaaldevan which was also shown in the first part.

The remaining movie will be on how Mahendra Bahubali reclaims the throne ."

Hers is No3 Shanky Rungta:

"Bhallaldev and his father would have blackmailed Sivagami by putting any intense conditions that would be very hard to deny and compelled and told her that Bhallal should be the king and not Bahubali.
As she already had committed that Bahubali will be the King, there wouldn't be any other way to remove him from the throne other than by getting him killed.
Sivagami, unwantedly would have asked Kattappa to do the same.
Kattappa, being the most loyal had followed the order by the mistress and killed BAHUBALI."

No4 by Prashant Rao:

"My guess is, the whole conspiracy revolves around "Bhalladeva" and his hatred towards his brother "Amarendra bahubali" and his wife, "Devasena", who rejected Bhalladeva(as mentioned in the movie)

Katappa was a man of integrity and one who could be trusted. It was mentioned in the beginning by kattappa that he was a slave to the throne . Also the queen Sivagami shouts out to the lord to save the child's life and not punish him for her mistakes.

Connecting these dots, my guess is that -

Bhalladeva would be made the king after the approval of the queen mother, Sivagami, due to a trail of events which could be -Bhalladeva repelling against the decision of the queen to make Bahubali the king since it was bhalladeva who killed the kalkeya king and he could ask for a "Trial by combat" resulting in the winner becoming the king. Bhalladeva happens to win the trail and is made king of the Mahishmati kingdom. The mistake that Sivagami mentions in the beggining could be the mistake of making Bhalladeva the king or even agreeing to conduct a trail by combat. Later on he would get Amarendra bahubali killed by kattappa.
Another situation could be that Bhalladeva could use some strong leverage against kattappa and forcefully make him kill Bahubali and later climb the throne and capture his wife, devasena. Fortunately, the queen Sivagami manages to escape from the kingdom with Amarendra bahubali's son who eventually takes his revenge and kills Bhalladeva"

And finally No5 by Vibhav Kshitz:

"Katappa killed Bahubali because he was instructed by Bahubali to kill himself.

Amrendra Bahubali has been presented as a humble, innocent king who happens to be a proficient strategist.

As he becomes the king of Mahishmati and marries Devasena( who was also admired by Bhallal Deva) the disputes between the brothers ignite.

Amrendra adores his brother Bhallal Deva, but he is also aware of the fact that Bhallal is planning to kill him and rule the Mahishmati is Dictorial Style rather than the Democratic one.

that is why, Amendra Bhahuballi tells Katappa to join the crusade of Bhallal Deva and become his informant.

Bhallal”s cunning brain doesn't trust Katappa(as he had sworn to protect the king and the kingdom) but Bhallal couldn't ignored the fact that Katappa was a skilled warrior. So he decides to keep Katappa at his side but with minimal information.

Lastly when Katappa learns that an attack will be performed on the king Bahuballi, Bahuballi tells Katappa to kill him(as he couldn't see any way out of it). He tells Katappa to kill him which would turn on Bhallal deva”s trust towards him(katappa). And once Katappa has Bhallal”s trust he could save Mahishmati

However, this plan didn't work because Amrendra Bahuballi didn't realise that Katappa cared for him more than he cared for the kingdom."

There you have it 5 of the wackiest theories we found on why Katappa Killed Baahubali

Updated : April 27, 2017 06:28 PM IST

Please Subscribe us OnGoogle News

Get latest news in Bollywood on Desi Martini Channel on Facebook. Join Now

Why Katappa killed Baahubali? Five Crazy Fan theories we found on Quora